On Searching for Generalized Instrumental Variables
نویسندگان
چکیده
Instrumental Variables are a popular way to identify the direct causal effect of a random variable X on a variable Y . Often no single instrumental variable exists, although it is still possible to find a set of generalized instrumental variables (GIVs) and identify the causal effect of all these variables at once. Till now it was not known how to find GIVs systematically or even test efficiently, if given variables satisfy GIV conditions. We provide fast algorithms for searching and testing restricted cases of GIVs. However, we prove that in the most general case it is NP-hard to verify if given variables fulfill the conditions of a general instrumental sets
منابع مشابه
On the Interpretation of Instrumental Variables in the Presence of Specification Errors
The method of instrumental variables (IV) and the generalized method of moments (GMM), and their applications to the estimation of errors-in-variables and simultaneous equations models in econometrics, require data on a sufficient number of instrumental variables that are both exogenous and relevant. We argue that, in general, such instruments (weak or strong) cannot exist.
متن کاملOn Searching for Generalized Instrumental Variables
function Find-Simple-IVs(G, X, Y ) Let B be all nodes d-separated from Y in G Let D = De(An(X)) Construct a flow graph F (G) with nodes: {V + | V ∈ D} ∪ {V |V ∈ An(X)} ∪ {S, Y } and edges: {V + → W | V,W ∈ An(D) and V ← W ∈ E} ∪ {V + → V − | V ∈ An(X)} ∪ {V − → W | V,W ∈ An(X) and V → W ∈ E} ∪ {S → V + | V ∈ (D ∩M ∩B)} ∪ {X → Y | X ∈ X} Assign capacities to nodes in G: infinite capacity to S, Y...
متن کاملSearching for the Origins of Schwab's Deliberative Curriculum Theory in the Thoughts of Aristotle, Dewey and Habermas
The main purpose of this study is exploring the roots and foundations of Schwab’s deliberative theory in curriculum. Therefore, after examining this theory in introduction, its foundations and origins were investigated. According to this, basic assumptions of this theory are practical and quasi practical arts, eclectic arts, commonplace and collective decision. Aristotle’s distinction between i...
متن کاملGeneralized instrumental variable models
The ability to allow for flexible forms of unobserved heterogeneity is an essential ingredient in modern microeconometrics. In this paper we extend the application of instrumental variable (IV) methods to a wide class of problems in which multiple values of unobservable variables can be associated with particular combinations of observed endogenous and exogenous variables. In our Generalized In...
متن کاملSargan’s Instrumental Variables Estimation and the Generalized Method of Moments
This article surveys J. D. Sargan’s work on instrumental variables (IV) estimation and its connections with the generalized method of moments (GMM). First the modeling context in which Sargan motivated IV estimation is presented. Then the theory of IV estimation as developed by Sargan is discussed. His approach to efficiency, his minimax estimator, tests of overidentification and underidentific...
متن کامل